top of page

What a Printed Proof Can Tell You

1 day ago
2 min read

Updated: 18 hours ago

Take a cookbook to the kitchen and prop it open beside a bowl. You have chopped the onions and heated the oil. The next instruction is on the other side of the page. Your fingers are covered in turmeric. At precisely this moment, the placement of a paragraph becomes a matter of some importance.


An open book drawn in oxblood ink

A proof copy lets an author try the book as a reader will use it. On screen, you can zoom in, scroll past a page break and lay two pages side by side. The printed book has a particular size, a binding and two pages visible at a time. Each of those decisions changes the experience of reading it.


Start with the part that asks the most of the reader. For a cookbook, follow one recipe with the proof open on the counter. For a textbook, find a diagram by following the reference in the chapter. For a journal, answer a prompt in your ordinary handwriting. A writing line can look generous on screen and still leave you halfway through a perfectly ordinary sentence.


Then sit in your usual reading chair and read three or four pages at your normal pace. Notice where you shift the book to catch the light or press a thumb against the gutter to make out a word. A pale caption, a cramped inner margin or a heading stranded at the foot of a page is easier to judge when you can point to the exact place your reading was interrupted.


Give each correction an address. “The table is hard to follow” leaves the designer guessing. “Page 48, second column: the last two figures run together” gives them a place to start. If a fix changes a page break, ask to see the following spread as well. A line gained on one page has to come from somewhere.


Finally, close the book and set it on a table. Look at the spine, turn it over and read the back. Then hand it to someone and watch where they open it. If they go straight to the recipe you tested, you may get the most useful verdict of the afternoon. Put the kettle on and let them cook.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page